Hailey Bieber is once again at the center of intense online speculation as unverified claims circulate suggesting she is deeply fixated on public commentary about her marriage to Justin Bieber. The renewed scrutiny comes amid legal action taken by the model and Rhode skincare founder against a TikTok creator who analyzed the couple’s relationship, sparking a viral debate across social media.
According to anonymous blind items now making the rounds online, Hailey allegedly spends hours each day watching content related to her marriage, with one claim suggesting she views as many as 1,000 videos daily. These allegations have not been independently verified, but they have fueled conversation following reports that she recently issued cease-and-desist letters to curb what she views as defamatory commentary.
The rumors gained traction after a gossip account alleged that a high-profile celebrity had become “obsessed and fixated” on how her relationship is discussed online and was increasingly resorting to legal threats in response. The same account later claimed the blinds were referring to Hailey, portraying her as deeply unsettled by public reaction to her marriage and criticism directed at her online behavior.
The controversy escalated earlier this month when screenshots circulated on TikTok appearing to show Hailey reposting a video by creator Julie Theis, who analyzed the Biebers’ relationship dynamics. In the video, Theis described Hailey as a “tolerant codependent,” arguing that such relationships can involve emotional imbalance. The creator also made broader claims about Justin Bieber’s personal struggles, which quickly drew backlash.
Many viewers interpreted the alleged repost as Hailey endorsing the analysis. However, she swiftly denied ever sharing the video and removed any trace of it from her accounts. In a statement posted on Instagram, Hailey pushed back strongly, saying she never reposted any content discussing her relationship and dismissed the claims as internet speculation.
Despite her denial, online skepticism persisted, with some users insisting they had screen recordings of the alleged repost before it disappeared. The situation intensified days later when legal representatives for the Biebers sent a cease-and-desist letter to Theis, accusing her of spreading false and damaging allegations. Theis later shared the letter publicly, criticizing the move as an attempt to silence her opinion and pointing out what she described as a contradiction between Hailey’s denial and the legal action.
The creator has continued to defend her commentary as opinion-based rather than factual, while Hailey’s camp maintains that the claims crossed into defamation. The dispute has only amplified online chatter, with fans and critics dissecting every development.
As rumors swirl about potential marital strain and Justin Bieber’s well-being, none of the more extreme claims have been substantiated. What is clear is that Hailey Bieber remains under relentless digital scrutiny, illustrating how celebrity marriages can become battlegrounds in the age of TikTok, blind items, and viral speculation—where even denials can fuel the fire further.
